Sugar Hill Sub & Deli

Located in the heart of Mays Landing, New Jersey, Sugar Hill Sub & Deli is a cherished local sandwich shop that has been delighting the community for over 30 years. Specializing in classic deli-style sandwiches and fast casual fare, Sugar Hill offers a genuinely nostalgic dining experience reminiscent of the beloved general stores from days gone by.

Step inside Sugar Hill and you’re greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere where friendly staff treat every customer like family. The aroma of fresh bread and savory meats fills the air, setting the stage for a truly satisfying meal. This spot has clearly mastered the art of crafting flavorful, well-made sandwiches that keep customers coming back time and again.

The menu is a treasure trove for sandwich enthusiasts. From their famous Italian Sub—layered with robust Boars Head meats, crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and just the right touch of mayo—to the tender and juicy Chicken Cheesesteak topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayo, every bite bursts with vibrant flavors. The Meatball Sub smothered in provolone cheese is comfort food at its best, while the Pork Roll Egg & Cheese offers a delightful twist for breakfast lovers.

For those seeking something lighter, Sugar Hill’s selection of fresh salads, such as the classic Caesar Salad, the hearty Chef’s Salad, and the flavorful Seafood Salad, provide satisfying options without sacrificing taste. Their array of tasty snacks, including locally adored Cincotti’s brownies and a variety of Tastykake treats, perfectly round out the meal.

Customers consistently praise the fast, friendly service. As one visitor noted, their sub arrived “in less than 5 minutes,” showcasing not only efficiency but an unwavering commitment to quality. Another customer, who traveled three hours just to try Sugar Hill, attests to the “freshness and on-point” quality of the subs, highlighting the deliciously ripe tomatoes and a memorable side of pepper shooters.

Sugar Hill Sub & Deli is more than just a sandwich shop—it’s a local institution where savory flavors meet genuine community spirit. Whether you're craving a classic American Hoagie, a hearty Tavern Ham & American Cheese Hoagie, or a sweet slice of Cinnamon French Toast Banana Bread, every visit promises to leave you utterly satisfied and eager to return.

With ample parking, a vast selection of chips and drinks, and an atmosphere that feels like home, Sugar Hill stands out as a must-visit deli in Mays Landing. If you find yourself in the area, make sure to stop by, because the authentic taste and warm hospitality here are something truly special.

Contact: 5445 Somers Point Rd, Mays Landing, NJ 08330 | (609) 625-0538